Alexandre Brierre de Boismont and the limits of the psychopathological gaze

One of the most remarkable implications of psychological medicine in the transition from the 18th century to the 19th was the advent of a new way of looking at the human being and new tools for analysing not only behaviour and individual experience, but also historical events, collective behavioural patterns or complex cultural achievements. Unsurprisingly, the deployment of this gaze could not advance without there being a series of disputes and controversies about its reach and the limits to its indiscriminate application. Focusing on the figure of French alienist Alexandre Brierre de Boismont and on the controversial cases of hallucinations and suicide, this article addresses the conflicts generated by the use of certain emblematic concepts and categories present in French psychological medicine throughout the central decades of the 19th century, as well as the essentially ambivalent relationship of the psychopathological point of view with the criticism of a culture which was made responsible, then as now, of a great number of psychological disorders and illnesses.